People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Wow wow wow! A hidden gem in the Subway! Decided to try this place out after seeing rave reviews and it did not disappoint! The service was great and the food was delicious. It is definitely a tight squeeze for everyone to fit, but that’s what makes it nice because it is such an intimate dining space. Make reservations to ensure you can get a table! Amazing food! ”
“ We came here on a busy Thursday, the bar was packed and still we were seated immediately . A group of 10 came in and Allie was able to accommodate instantly. Allie is probably the most efficient waitress ever. We had waters (with ice) 2 mins after being seated. Our drinks came promptly and a few minutes later she checked on us to make sure our drinks were good . She’s amazing. 10/10 will be back ”
“ My wife saw this amazing pizza place on TikTok, and it’s located in a train station next to a bar. I love pizza, and this place did not disappoint. The Caesar salad was incredible. I loved the breadcrumbs instead of traditional croutons. We ordered the pepperoni ‘cup’ pizza (love that they call it that), and it was easily one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had, and I’ve had a lot of pizza. The vibes were really fun, and the service was great. Highly recommend! ”
“ Outstanding pizza. We ordered the Funghi it did not disappoint and also half cheese half pepperoni! We ate every bite. Prices are great and the people are super friendly! We almost didn’t go because it is down the stairway to the subway! Looks are deceiving! One bite and we were hooked! ”
“ Hidden in plain sight under the NYC streets, See No Evil Pizza (@seenoevilpizza) is a serious gem you have to check out. Located inside a subway station at 210 W 50th St, it’s got this wild 80s punk rock vibe that just hits different. I kicked things off with the Spring Fava — crispy panelle, pickled spring onions, and bright lemon conserva. Fresh, punchy, and totally addicting. But the real star? The Margherita pie — perfectly thin crust, rich tomato sauce, fresh basil, and oozy mozzarella. Simple, classic, but out of this world. Every bite tasted like New York at its finest. See No Evil isn’t just a pizza spot — it’s an experience. Go for the vibes, stay for the pies. #SeeNoEvilPizza #NYCPizza #PizzaLover #HiddenGemsNYC #FoodieInTheBigApple2025 ”
“ Great little pizza place, below ground at the subway entrance, right across the street from Gershwin Theater. Pizzas were very, very good. They say personal pizzas, but could definitely be split between two people if you order a salad or other side. Staff was very nice, highly recommend! ”
“ I stumbled across see no evil when I was on a business trip last fall. My fave pizza in the area! I’m back in the city with my family and took them for dinner. My husband who usually doesn’t eat the crust on pizza actually crushed the entire pepperoni pizza. My son really enjoyed the Margherita pizza we shared. We decided to come here for a 2nd time and made reservations for a Friday night. So glad we did because it was busy! Highly recommend grabbing pizza from here if you’re in the area! Staff were also very friendly. I’d make a reservation on expected busier nights to be safe. ”
“ Awesome place!! I did not even know it was underground literally in the subway, and just took my visiting nephew there! Then I checked the website to make sure it was clean, good. Rave reviews. Wow do it was really cool for him to eat there. And the pizza is like real Italian pizza, it’s amazing. Thin Neapolitan bottom crust but with the fluffy flaky side crust. Great Arabic (Rice meat balls) too, great other side dishes/antipastas , small and warm and people filling it then refilling it, just a special spot. ”
Menu
Paul Laurent Cuvee du Fondateur Brut NV, Champagne, France
US$100.00Chianti
US$14.00Pet Nat
US$17.00Sparkling Rose
US$17.00Negroamaro
US$17.00
About
See No Evil Pizza
If you’re wandering through New York City and find yourself near the subway, take a moment to discover a culinary gem tucked beneath the bustling streets: See No Evil Pizza. Located at 210 W 50th St Concourse #1, this unique spot offers an unexpected twist on traditional pizza dining, combining punk rock vibes with culinary excellence.
As you descend into the subway confluence, you might be surprised by the intimate atmosphere of this hidden spot. The reviews speak volumes; customers rave about the impeccable service and mouth-watering dishes. Jeanine F. captures the essence perfectly, describing it as a “hidden gem” where each bite reaffirms its rave-worthy reputation. If you’re among the intrepid diners, make a reservation and brace yourself for an unforgettable experience.
What makes See No Evil Pizza stand out is its brilliant menu. For example, John DePasquale’s enthusiasm for their pepperoni ‘cup’ pizza is echoed by many, highlighting a rich tomato sauce, crisp edges, and gooey mozzarella that provide a satisfying crunch with every bite. And don't overlook the clever twist on a classic Caesar salad, enhanced with breadcrumbs, offering a delightful departure from tradition.
For those seeking something bold, there’s the Margherita pie. Described as “out of this world” by guests, its perfectly thin crust paired with fresh basil and quality ingredients exemplifies New York pizza at its finest. Pair this with the intriguing Spring Fava appetizer, a crispy panelle dish that hits every flavor note — fresh, bright, and utterly intoxicating.
While the space may feel snug, that very coziness enhances the inviting mood, creating an atmosphere where food enthusiasts gather for a shared love of pizza. Aimee Lozowski also attests to the friendly service, proving that even in a bustling subway station, See No Evil Pizza delivers a standout dining experience.
In a city teeming with options, See No Evil Pizza shines bright as an experience worth having. With every slice, you not only taste the flavor of New York but also the energy that surrounds it. So next time you hear the rumble of the subway, remember there's more than just transportation below; there's pizza waiting to be discovered.
Book a table